When I’m feeling especially glum about the current state of political affairs, I idly wonder whether the portents of danger are greater in the U.S. or Germany. Which provokes more fear: the rise of Trump and Cruz in the U.S. or the rise of the far right Alternative for Germany which now has seats in half of Germany’s state parliaments? Compounding my sense of gloom is the threat of terrorism that looms over both countries.
I scan the news for reassurance, looking for facts that will allay my fears. The AfD’s overall support in Germany, according to a new poll, is at 14%, one point higher than for the Greens. That’s bad news, but the combined support for Germany’s two main parties, Merkel’s CDU and the SPD, is 55%. Merkel herself maintains a 54% approval rating according to last month’s survey by the ARD broadcasting network, not bad for a leader who has been under siege for opening Germany’s doors to refugees.
I googled Donald Trump’s approval rating and was surprised to learn that, according to both Gallup and HuffPost, it’s about 30%. That doesn’t seem very high for a candidate who’s mopping up Republican primary votes across the U.S. But how many people are actually voting in the presidential primaries? Here are some astonishing statistics from the Pew Research Center:
Through the first 12 primaries of 2016, combined Republican turnout has been 17.3% of eligible voters – the highest of any year since at least 1980. Democratic turnout so far is 11.7% – the highest since 1992, with the notable exception of the extraordinarily high turnout in 2008.
My confidence in American democracy had been waning for years before we moved to Germany. Partisanship, ignorance, apathy….it was all so depressing. Germany has serious political problems to contend with, but Germans have much higher voter turnout than Americans and by most accounts they are better informed.
“I could sit on the ground and weep. I’d forgotten what is was like to be in a country where people read,” says Thomas Geoghegan in Were You Born on the Wrong Continent? I highly recommend Geoghegan’s book to anyone exasperated with quality of life issues in America. His persuasive and entertaining work makes a solid case for European social democracy, especially the German model.
There are some disturbing political trends in Germany right now, but I hope the higher levels of political engagement and participation here will prevent extremists from making further gains. Now that fewer refugees are arriving and relief workers have more time to manage the situation, there is reason to hope.
Donna Swarthout 
Thank you for this post. The german democracy is pretty young and i think we are in the middle of the first real crisis of it. But i also trust that the thinking people will figuere out what i s really behind the AFD and will read theri weird program.
Thank you Donna,
These thoughts are definately on my mind as a dual US German citizen,
( repatriated under Article 116 ).
After having dinner with a young German professor here in North Carolina who seemed, unlike myself, unconcerned about much of anything, whether its was Afd & the rise of the right in Europe or Trump fueled hate here.
Or after reading an in depth article on Petra & AFd and what was for me an amazing similarity of denial of reality within the right wing, this morning finds America’s home grown narcissistic sociopath not unsurprisingly, self destructing before our eyes.
It is still sad too watch that we have hit this bottom.
Is it too much to hope that humanities tendencies, both good and bad, will lean towards our better half?
Well it is really a question of what IS our better half and how soon the change will come but, history has moved in the preferred direction, what with some pretty terrible detours.
As for my own frustration with America, centralized media, populist apathy and the weakening of Democracy Bernie Sanders definately showed me INTELLIGENT progressive interest is alive and well. And Clinton integrated 80% of his platform into hers. Now we’ll see what that gets us.
Still we have a lot of work to do and a long way to go. As the say about the USA, we are great at creating wealth and pretty poor at distributing it. For that we can certainly look to Europe & Germany for some guidance.
I too have hope like the above commenter,
just a bit more long winded I guess.