Closure doesn’t come easily for relatives of a Holocaust victim. More than ten years ago I discovered my great aunt Meta, a member of my father’s family who was left in Frankfurt when the family escaped to America. I did a lot of research and writing about Meta back then, and helped to organize a stolperstein memorial for her, but unanswered questions still nag at me.
Why was Meta denied a U.S immigration visa even though my grandparents, my father and his sister got theirs? What happened to Meta after the family left for New York and before she was deported? Were there any additional records about her fate that I had not yet uncovered?
I spent a good part of the last six months researching these questions (again!). I’ve contacted three museums and historical institutes in Frankfurt am Main, all of which sent prompt replies with little new information. American institutions have been less responsive. My December 2021 inquiry to the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum has not been answered. And I’ve received no reply to my request sent last August to the U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Services to search for a copy of my family’s visa file. Although the agency offers this service for a fee, the average processing time is 180 business days.
The most significant new item I’ve uncovered is a photo with an aerial view of the Judenhaus (ghetto house) where Meta lived before she was deported (not for online publication though). However, I did learn a lot about U.S. immigration policies during the Nazi years and some of the changes in refugee law since World War II.
Despite great strides in protections for refugees, there are still inequities in how governments treat asylum claims. My latest article, Echoes of the Past in Europe’s Two-Tier Approach to Refugees, connects Meta’s experience with the fate of people seeking refuge during the humanitarian crises of today. Meta’s story has relevance for the thousands of displaced persons currently seeking refuge in Europe and elsewhere.
Donna Swarthout 
Hi, Donna â
I hope you and your family are well. Your message about your great aunt Meta resonated with me. I am trying to finish my book about my family and I think the only closure available is telling the family story.
What was Metaâs last name? Where did she live in Frankfurt? My grandparents were deported from Frankfurt so I have several books about the deportations from Frankfurt. I would be happy to look through them to see if your auntâs name is there.
Have you tried Ancestry.com for immigration questions about your family? I am able to use it for free through my library. If you canât get it, I would be happy to search for you.
Where did you write for the immigration file of your family and how much is the fee? I havenât done that as part of my family research and always have the hope I will find something more.
You are doing something important in trying to find out more about your great aunt. Donât give up!
Warm regards,
Dena
Hi Dena, so nice to hear from you. Meta Adler was deported in May 1942 from a Judenhaus in Ostendstr. and my understanding from the City of Frankfurt is that the records from the deportation were destroyed. I believe I have all of the available documentation about her life that still exists. The purpose of my renewed research was to learn more about the U.S. immigration process and why her visa application was denied, which is the subject of my linked article at the end of my post. You can request a visa records search through the INS (Form G-1041). It’s a two-part process and each part costs $65 and involves a 180 business day waiting period. Sending you warm wishes, Donna